Quiescent Galaxies: Standard Candles Or Not?

are quiesent galaxies standard candles

Standard candles are objects with known luminosities that are used to determine the distance to celestial objects. The relationship between a celestial body's luminosity and distance can be computed using the inverse-square law. In 1908, Henrietta Swan Leavitt studied Cepheid variables, a type of star, and discovered the relationship between their period and luminosity. Leavitt's work on Cepheid variables and Edwin Hubble's subsequent distance calculations using this relationship revealed that the Andromeda Nebula was, in fact, a galaxy external to the Milky Way. Today, Type Ia supernovae are considered standard candles and are used to determine the distances to galaxies. However, recent findings have suggested that not all Type Ia supernovae may conform to the standard candle model, and that other objects, such as quasars, could be used as new standard candles.

cycandle

What are standard candles?

A standard candle is an astronomical object with a known absolute magnitude. They are important to astronomers as they can be used to determine the distance to an object. The distance (d) to an object can be computed using the formula: d = 10^[(m-M)/5], where m is the apparent magnitude of the object, M is the absolute magnitude of the object, and d is the distance to the object in parsecs.

The most commonly used standard candles in astronomy are Cepheid Variable stars, RR Lyrae stars, and Type Ia supernovae. Cepheid Variable stars were the key instrument in Edwin Hubble's 1923 conclusion that M31 (Andromeda) was an external galaxy, and in the discovery that the universe is expanding and galaxies are drifting apart. However, there are several problems that complicate the use of Cepheids as standard candles, including the nature and linearity of the period-luminosity relation in various passbands and the impact of metallicity on the relations.

RR Lyrae variables are used for measuring distances within the galaxy and in nearby globular clusters. In galactic astronomy, X-ray bursts on the surface of a neutron star are used as standard candles. Type Ia supernovae are considered reliable standard candles because of their cosmic uniformity and the same intrinsic brightness.

Quasars have also been proposed as a new type of standard candle. Astronomers have found that the X-ray and ultraviolet luminosities of quasars are tightly correlated and can be used to determine cosmic distances.

cycandle

How are quiescent galaxies' distances measured?

Quiescent galaxies are faint and red, making them extremely challenging to study. The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has confirmed the existence of a large number of galaxies in the first few hundred million years of cosmic history, with some of them becoming quiescent as early as 1.5 billion years after the Big Bang.

One such quiescent galaxy, GS-9209, has been identified at redshift z = 4.658, just 1.25 billion years after the Big Bang. Its size was measured using the JWST Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) F210M-band imaging, which has a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of around 0.07". The effective radius of the stellar component of GS-9209 was measured to be re = 0.033 ± 0.003", with a Sérsic index of n = 2.3 ± 0.3.

To measure the distances to these distant galaxies, astronomers use a series of techniques known as the cosmic distance ladder. One foundational method in this ladder is parallax, which involves measuring the angle between two objects as seen from different locations. While parallax is effective for nearby stars, space telescopes like Gaia have expanded its usefulness. Another technique involves comparing the observed brightness of a supernova (SN) with its intrinsic brightness, which is known as its classification. By comparing the known luminosity of an object with its observed brightness, the distance to the object can be calculated using the inverse-square law. These objects of known brightness are called standard candles, a term coined by Henrietta Swan Leavitt, who discovered that Cepheid stars vary periodically with a period related to their intrinsic luminosity.

In addition to Cepheid variables, other indicators of distance include RR Lyrae variables, which are used for measuring distances within the galaxy and in nearby globular clusters, and X-ray bursts on the surface of a neutron star, which are used as standard candles in galactic astronomy. However, the use of Cepheid variables as standard candles is complicated by several factors, including the nature and linearity of the period-luminosity relation and the impact of metallicity on the zero-point and slope of these relations.

cycandle

What are the challenges of using standard candles?

Standard candles are objects and phenomena that, according to theories of stellar evolution, supernova physics, and galaxy evolution, are expected to have a fixed luminosity. By comparing the apparent brightness of these objects to their intrinsic brightness, astronomers can determine their distance. However, there are several challenges associated with using standard candles:

Uncertainties in Theories and Models

Theoretical uncertainties exist in our understanding of stellar evolution, supernova physics, and galaxy evolution. These uncertainties can affect the accuracy of distance calculations based on standard candles.

Difficulties in Observations

Observational challenges, such as photometric contamination (blending) and varying extinction laws, can impact the precision of brightness measurements. These factors introduce uncertainties when comparing observed brightness to intrinsic brightness.

Propagating Errors

The cosmic distance ladder, a series of techniques used to measure distances in the universe, relies on each step building upon the previous one. As a result, errors in the nearer steps, both systematic and statistical, propagate and accumulate in the more distant steps. This limits the precision of distance measurements, especially for more distant objects.

"Standardness" and Homogeneity

There are concerns about the true homogeneity of standard candles in terms of their absolute magnitude. For example, Type Ia supernovae, commonly considered standard candles, may exhibit variations in peak brightness due to differences in the masses or compositions of the stars involved. Correcting for these differences and ensuring the "standardness" of objects is a complex task.

Limitations of Specific Standard Candles

Different types of standard candles have their limitations. For instance, Cepheid variables, a commonly used standard candle, have complications due to the nature and linearity of the period-luminosity relation and the impact of metallicity on their distances. Additionally, RR Lyrae variables, while useful for measuring distances within the galaxy, are less luminous than Cepheids and may require intensive monitoring for distance estimation in more distant galaxies.

Despite these challenges, astronomers have developed techniques, such as the cosmic distance ladder, to calibrate and improve the accuracy of standard candles. The search for better standard candles, such as quasars and kilonovae, also continues to advance our understanding of the cosmos.

Candles: Self-Extinguishing or Not?

You may want to see also

cycandle

What are the alternative methods to standard candles?

A standard candle is an astronomical object with a known absolute magnitude. They are used by astronomers to determine the distance to an object by comparing its known luminosity to its observed brightness.

There are several alternative methods and indicators that can be used to measure distances in the universe, beyond the use of standard candles. Here are some of those methods:

  • Parallax: This is a foundational method in the cosmic distance ladder, which is a series of techniques used to measure distances in the universe. Parallax is effective for measuring the distances of nearby stars, and space telescopes have expanded its effectiveness significantly. It remains the most direct and reliable method for measuring stellar distances and is used to calibrate other indirect methods.
  • Eclipsing binaries: In recent years, eclipsing binaries have become feasible indicators of distance. They offer a direct method to estimate the distance to galaxies with improved accuracy, made possible with current technology.
  • RR Lyrae variables: These are used for measuring distances within the galaxy and in nearby globular clusters. RR Lyrae variables are less luminous than Cepheids and are part of the old stellar populations.
  • X-ray bursts: In galactic astronomy, X-ray bursts on the surface of a neutron star are used as standard candles. The X-ray flux at the peak of the burst corresponds to Eddington luminosity, which can be calculated with the assumed mass of the neutron star. This method is used for distance determination of some low-mass X-ray binaries.
  • Quasars: Astronomers have proposed using quasars as new standard candles due to their tightly correlated X-ray and ultraviolet luminosities, even at large cosmological distances.
  • Globular cluster luminosity function: This method compares the luminosities of globular clusters in distant galaxies to that of the Virgo Cluster. It carries an uncertainty of about 20% in distance estimation.
  • Other indicators: Novae, Tip of the Red-Giant Branch (TRGB), and Kilonovae have all been mentioned as potential indicators of distance in the universe.

While these methods provide alternatives to standard candles, it is worth noting that the precision of distance measurements in astronomy is often poorer for more distant objects, and the ""standardness"" of the brightest candles in terms of their homogeneity is a concern.

cycandle

What are the benefits of using standard candles?

A standard candle is an astronomical object with a known absolute magnitude. They are used to determine the distance to an object by comparing its apparent brightness to its intrinsic brightness. The most commonly used standard candles are Cepheid Variable stars and RR Lyrae stars, whose absolute magnitudes can be determined from their variability period.

The benefits of using standard candles are:

  • They provide a way to measure distances in the universe, which is a foundational method in the cosmic distance ladder.
  • They allow for the calibration of more indirect methods of measuring distances, such as using the parallax of nearby stars to determine their distance.
  • They can be used to study the evolution of galaxies by comparing the observed brightness of a supernova with its intrinsic brightness, and then comparing that with the host galaxy's velocity (its redshift).
  • They can be used to discover new objects and phenomena in the universe, such as quasars, which have been proposed as a new type of standard candle.
  • They help calibrate other objects' luminosities, which can then be used to determine distances to more distant objects in the universe.

While standard candles are extremely useful to astronomers, there are some challenges to their use. For example, the calibration process is difficult, and uncertainties in theories and models, as well as difficulties in observations, can introduce uncertainty into the results. Additionally, not all objects classified as standard candles have the same peak brightness, and differences in their peak luminosities must be corrected for.

Frequently asked questions

Standard candles are objects of known brightness. By comparing the known luminosity of an object to its observed brightness, its distance can be computed using the inverse-square law.

Standard candles include spectrally classified stars on the stellar main sequences, certain types of variable stars, the relationship between a galaxy's rotation speed and its luminosity, and Type Ia supernovae.

Type Ia supernovae are the result of the thermonuclear explosion of a white dwarf star. They are superb standard candles because they all have about the same luminosity. Their distance can be calibrated with the Tully-Fisher and Faber-Jackson relations.

One of the fundamental problems with standard candles is determining their luminosity in the first place. Another issue is that not all standard candles may be standard. For example, non-standard Type Ia supernovae are more common than previously thought, and the Hubble constant as measured by Type Ia supernovae differs from other methods.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment